Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

Article PY 550 Article Review Guidelines For this assignment, you are to write a scholarly/academic

September 23, 2024

Article

PY 550 Article Review Guidelines

For this assignment, you are to write a scholarly/academic “critical review” for each of two journal articles you choose from those provided. Each review should be at least 2-3 pages in length (not including title and reference pages).

Q: What is a critical review?

A: The word “critical” does not mean to criticize negatively, but rather to thoughtfully evaluate the quality of the paper.

Structure of a Critical Review

The review will include
an introduction, summary, evaluation, and
conclusion. (plus title page and reference page)

Introduction

1. Introduce the author(s), title, and topic of the article.

2. Make a brief statement about the purpose of the study and findings, or in the case of a conceptual/theoretical paper, the key arguments or propositions presented. Don’t go into detail here, you will do that in the summary

3. Make a very brief statement that “previews” your evaluation/critique of the article.

Summary

In this section, your goal is to convey the content of the article in a very concise and unbiased manner. There should not be any critique in the summary. To write an accurate summary, you must read and seek to fully comprehend the entire paper so that you may summarize in your own words (i.e., paraphrase) in a way that accurately reflects that which you have read. After reading the paper, reflect on its purpose, main points, and conclusions. Determining the main points of the article can sometimes be challenging. As you read, it may serve you well to create an outline of the article. Two very important guidelines are relevant to writing the summary.

1. Many of us were taught that paraphrasing involves rearranging or replacing a few words from the source text so that you make the same statement using slightly different words. This is in fact, NOT proper paraphrasing. This is inadequate, and is actually a form of plagiarism. Please see the APA publication manual for guidance on paraphrasing and avoiding plagiarism.

2. Also, as a rule, you should avoid using word for word passages from the source text. This rule can occasionally be broken when the author has made a statement in such a way that to paraphrase would substantially lower its impact. Any word for word passage should be put in quotation marks, of course.

Evaluation

Think of this section as the critique. This will be the longest section of your paper. Here, you’ll discuss strengths, weaknesses, and the most notable, interesting, or controversial points. Your discussion should be well reasoned and not simple opinion with nothing to back it up. It is also better to avoid statements such as “I believe,” “I think,” and “Personally,…” You may certainly believe something to be true and of course you have an opinion, however it is better not to use an “I believe” statement. Simply begin stating the arguments or facts upon which your opinion is based. There are many alternative phrases that work well, such as “Based on ________, it could be argued that _______.” Also, where needed, consider citing other sources to help bolster your commentary. This is useful for both disputing/questioning and supporting claims made in the article you are evaluating.

The overall structure of the evaluation/critique portion of your paper is a matter of preference and will differ according to what works best for the type of article you are reviewing. However, in every case, there should be a structure. In other words, your writing shouldn’t jump around with disconnected, rambling ideas and statements. There should be a flow that makes it coherent.

Here are some suggestions for structure.

· Order your commentary about the paper according to importance of each point or topic. This can be done either from most important to least important or reversed, i.e., from least important to most important.

· If your evaluation is more positive than negative, present the negative points first and the positive last. Likewise, if there is more negative than positive, then present the positive points first and the negative last. Doing this will provide an easy transition to your conclusion.

Conclusion

This is a fairly short paragraph.

Restate your claims (above), but don’t be redundant. Restating doesn’t mean repeating the exact statements that you have already made. Think of this as a super concise summary of your evaluation section.

End with possible recommendations.

References

List all sources used in the review. If no other sources are cited, then only the article you reviewed will be in the reference page.

>Psychology homework help

Share This Post

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Textbook: Physiology of Behavior, Physiology of Behavior Neil R. Carlson and Melissa A. Birkett Pearson Thirteenth Edition 2021

working on a final project Overview The final project for this course is the creation of a six-month merchandise plan for the women’s dresses

working on a final project Overview The final project for this course is the creation of a six-month merchandise plan for the women’s dresses department. The final product represents an authentic demonstration of competency because it provides an authentic experience of completing a buying plan. The final deliverable will be

Age: 33 years old T- 100.0 P- 108 R 20 180/110 Ht 5’6 Wt 146lbs Background: Lisa is in a Naples, FL detox facility thinking about long term rehab. She is

Age: 33 years old T- 100.0 P- 108 R 20 180/110 Ht 5’6 Wt 146lbs Background: Lisa is in a Naples, FL detox facility thinking about long term rehab. She is considering treatment for her Hep C+ but needs to get clean first. She has been abusing opiates, approximately $100

Describe the role of testosterone in creating sexual arousal. Would arousal still occur without testosterone? What hormones affect arousal in

Describe the role of testosterone in creating sexual arousal. Would arousal still occur without testosterone? What hormones affect arousal in women? Response Parameters Initial Post · Each initial post should include a minimum of 250 words of actual text (i.e., the 250 word minimum does not include your reference) ·

300 word discussion 2 references/intext citation Due 3/24/2024 Last week’s module covered Latent Print Identification and provided numerous articles

300 word discussion 2 references/intext citation Due 3/24/2024 Last week’s module covered Latent Print Identification and provided numerous articles involving the “issues” in the field. This week’s articles involve various research studies involving the accuracy of Latent Print Examinations. Taking into consideration the information covered in the presentation and these

5-3 Final Project Milestone Two: Annotated Bibliography Submit your annotated bibliography for the final project. For additional details, please

5-3 Final Project Milestone Two: Annotated Bibliography Submit your annotated bibliography for the final project. For additional details, please refer to the Milestone Two Guidelines and Rubric

Module 3 Discussion Pulmonary Function: D.R. is a 27-year-old man, who presents to the nurse practitioner at the Family Care Clinic

Module 3 Discussion Pulmonary Function: D.R. is a 27-year-old man, who presents to the nurse practitioner at the Family Care Clinic complaining of increasing SOB, wheezing, fatigue, cough, stuffy nose, watery eyes, and postnasal drainage—all of which began four days ago. Three days ago, he began monitoring his peak flow

are citizen review or advisory boards a necessary complement to policing and police administration.

Read the case of Peterson v. AT&T in Chapter 51. In your thread, post your case summary, using the briefing method .

i have a assignment due for a capstone class further details to be discussed upon acceptance

Foundations of Group Work and Types of Therapy Video Reference: Henson, B. A. (2017, April 27).

Foundations of Group Work and Types of Therapy Video Reference: Henson, B. A. (2017, April 27). Role play: Group counseling for adolescents with anxietyLinks to an external site. [Video]. YouTube. In a 3 page paper, identify the video you selected and address the following: · What group therapy techniques were demonstrated? How well do you believe these techniques were demonstrated? · What evidence

Hello Everyone, Starting this weeks discussion, I chose to talk about ethical issues that forensic psychology professionals are likely to encounter

Hello Everyone, Starting this weeks discussion, I chose to talk about ethical issues that forensic psychology professionals are likely to encounter while working with the military or the emergence of an alternative to criminal court. The military justice system is unique from the civilian criminal justice system, and forensic psychologists

Hello, I need assistance with the following assignment, which I already had done once but the professor did not agree with the way it was done. Please find a

Hello, I need assistance with the following assignment, which I already had done once but the professor did not agree with the way it was done. Please find attached the assignment, the way it was a

ASSIGNMENT OVERVIEW In the first assignment you examined primary sources, the raw material that historians use to interpret the past. In this assignment

ASSIGNMENT OVERVIEW In the first assignment you examined primary sources, the raw material that historians use to interpret the past. In this assignment you will analyze secondary sources: articles written by historians. Scholarly historical articles are based on a historian’s interpretation of primary sources and other secondary literature. With this assignment

Greece Greek architecture and art: searching for perfection in proportion of forms and parts while creating the ideal image Focus on Greece: 4

Greece Greek architecture and art: searching for perfection in proportion of forms and parts while creating the ideal image Focus on Greece: 4 periods Geometric or Orientalizing Period: (c. 100-650 B.C.E.) Little survives from this early period. Mud-brick temples and tombs ae chief architectural forms. Vases are the dominant surviving

Scenario Assume the role of the chief operations strategist for a multi-specialty health care organization. You have determined that the organization

Scenario Assume the role of the chief operations strategist for a multi-specialty health care organization. You have determined that the organization could benefit from creating a workforce management strategy for the purpose of optimizing staffing levels. With worsening staffing shortages in critical areas such as nursing and primary care physicians,

Watch the video, then evaluate the speech by addressing the following: · Audience: What was the speaker’s target audience? How do you know? · Introduction:

Watch the video, then evaluate the speech by addressing the following: · Audience: What was the speaker’s target audience? How do you know? · Introduction: Identify the speaker’s attention-getter, topic, and thesis. Did the attention-getter grab your interest? Why or why not? What was the speaker’s thesis or central idea?

Select and research one of the positions we learned about this week. 2. Explain the roles and responsibilities associated with this position. 3.

Select and research one of the positions we learned about this week. 2. Explain the roles and responsibilities associated with this position. 3. Discuss the type of position you would like to pursue in the law. Explain why this particular position interests you. Paralegals or Legal Assistants assist

Our Services

Article PY 550 Article Review Guidelines For this assignment, you are to write a scholarly/academic

Share This Post

Related Questions

Use Our 6 Free Tools